Mechanical quality of welds in polyethylene pipe systems. Cracking andor crazing can be defined as a fracture or surface breakage in the material of a molded part, usually found in weld line areas, but also on the surface in general. Experimental study of stress cracking in high density. The escr of polyethylene, one of the most widely used plastic materials, is of particular concern in the plastics industry and is the subject of this investigation. Polyethylene flooring vs pvc and pp flooring materials.
Jan 18, 2011 hence, an important design factor for pe pipes became commonly known as environmental stress cracking resistance escr, which led to the development of mdpe. Cracks in corners when cracks appear in the corners of plastic parts, the cause is too much plastic shrinkage onto the mold core in that corner. Sodium hypochlorite is available as solutions in varying strengths. Many homeowners believe pvc to be a maintenancefree product, however, which may or may not be accurate depending on its application. Definition of environmental stress cracking esc environmental stress cracking esc in plastics means the failure at about room temperature due to continuously acting external andor internal stresses in the presence of surface active substances known as stress cracking agents such as alcohols, soaps, dyes, agents containing moisture. Stress cracking is essentially a brittle cracking phenomenon that occurs at a constant stress lower than the short term yield strength or break strength of the material. Stress cracking in upvc and high impact pipes in the natural. Comparison of different pond liner materials which is. Hdpe pipe, polyethylene pe pipe are sorted by strength classified according to the intensity of the earlier technological developments.
The effects of recycled high density polyethylene hdpe and nanoclay on the stress crack resistance scr of pristine hdpe were evaluated using the notched constant ligament stress ncls test. This paper describes various forms of stress corrosion cracking in polyethylene and discusses them on the basis of practical examples of polyethylene steel pipe coatings. The test data were analyzed by both linear elastic fracture mechanics lefm and elastic plastic fracture mechanics epfm. In view of these figures it is clear that the netherlands next to the usa has the most experience in the use of pvc pipe lines for gas.
Other common plastic materials used for piping include polyvinyl chloride pvc, polypropylene pp, polybutylene pb and acrylonitrilebutadienestyrene abs. Environmental stress crack resistance of polyethylene under. Most studies on the environmental stress cracking of polyethylene focus on the. Many of the hdpe covers are rated at 20 years or more, while a budget pvc tarp may not last even three years in the sun before hardening and cracking. Concentrated solutions for disinfection purposes may contain 10% to 18% available chlorine while domestic and laundry bleaches typically contain 3% to 6% available chlorine. Although stress cannot be eliminated, excessive stress can be molded into the parts by using too high an injection pressure, too high a holding pressure, or. The 100year stress crack resistance scr of corrugated hdpe pipes was evaluated using a 600 mm diameter pipe. Todays approach to stress corrosion cracking in polyethylene coatings of steel pipes for standard applications in water and gas distribution systems merely considers the coating types featuring the low peeling resistance of the early editions of din 30670, i.
Comparison of different pond liner materials which is best. Such myths are either wholly wrong or correct just part of the time. Geomembranes made from high density polyethylene hope have a high percent crystallinity and are therefore of concern with regard to stress cracking. Comparison of pvc and hdpe geomembranes geomembrane. Since the introduction of the first 2liter, onepiece pet bottle by continental can co. The lefm approach uses the stress intensity factor k to define the two failure mechanisms. Piano keys of san failed by stresscracking at a point where they picked up a. Environmental stress crack resistance service temperatures up to 60c 140f is highly resistant to a wide variety of rather reactive cracking of escr is carried out on molded specimens 18 in. The study was made possible by targeted localization of coating holidays using various methods of cathodic corrosion protection ccp and the following subsequent examinations of the damages and especially the change of. Since pvc geomembrane is an amorphous material, it is not subject to environmental stress cracking. Also, if the ejection speed is too great, the plastic will not have time to conform to the normal stress being applied and cracks will form from distortion.
When you consider durability and service life, a2000 pvc. Some types of highdensity polyethylene have good resistance against. A2000 d2000 pvc pipe for storm sewers and drainage. Since variance of any of these factors can change the environmental stresscrack resistance of the container, the test results are representative only of a given test performed under defined conditions in. Environmental stress crack resistance of polyethylene stress crack reagent concentration. Hdpe pipe pressure classes that can be made between pn4pn32 and the production of the desired diameter and size of hdpe pressure pipe system has undergone many tests in 1950, particularly in the carriage of drinking water. Pvc pipe is not threatened by this type of cracking. The black color increases pipe temperature from radiant heat.
Nor does pvc geomembrane stress crack when exposed to multiaxial stresses. Environmental stress cracking resistance of polyethylene. Environmental stress cracking may account for around 1530% of all plastic. Environmental stress cracking esc is not the result of the continual battle that the plastics industry has in convincing environmentalists and politicians that plastics can be the solution to environmental problems and not the cause esc is the consequence of a combination of mechanical stress and exposure to an aggressive chemical. Stress cracking in upvc and high impact pipes in the. Under loading or localized tensile stress, m294 hdpe pipe is subject to environmental stress crackingalso known as slow crack growth. Experimental study of stress cracking in high density polyethylene pipe. While pvc is the more common of the two, high density polyethylene is used in specific circumstances that make polyvinyl chloride unattractive or unsuitable. Injection molded part defects cracks in molded parts.
Pvc and m294 hdpe pipe do not provide equal longterm durability performance. The environmental stress cracking esc effects on pvc of various high ph sodium hydroxide environments have been studied. Mdpe has good shock absorption and is more resistant to notching and stress cracking than hdpe. Wire and cable polymer compounds thermal stress cracking. Hdpe pipes and fittings polyethylene piping systems. It serves several objectives, for instance, to evaluate stress corrosion, installation. Pvc was tested by several methods, including monotonic creep method,73. Investigations on environmental stress cracking resistance. Each size and grade or schedule of pvc pipe is rated to a maximum fluid pressure. It is commonly used for both rigid containers and plastic films. This is because stress from different sources increases during the summertime.
Environmental stress cracking, often referred to as esc, causes a stressed plastics part to become brittle and crack when in contact with a wide range of fluids that act as stress cracking agents. Exhibited as premature rupture, this phenomenon can occur when stressed hdpe plastics are attacked by a reagent even storm runoff that causes cracking or rupture at stress levels well below design performance expectations. Moldedin stress can be another contributor to stresscracking. Investigations on environmental stress cracking resistance of. In general, the mechanism of environmental stress cracking in polyethylene. Polyethylene is formed by the polymerization of compounds containing an unsaturated bond between two carbon atoms. Environmental stress cracking in polyethylene takes place because of interlamellar failure, which. Highdensity polyethylene or hdpe is a commonly used petroleum thermoplastic and the most used of the three polyethylenes for a wide range of applications.
Because parts made with vistamaxx enhanced hdpe are tougher than those made with pure hdpe, they are less likely to fail through environmental stress cracking. Pvc liners also have great chemical resistance and are moderately strong against tears and punctures. Environmental stress crack resistance of polyethylene introduction to environmental stress cracking and escr over the past decade, highdensity polyethylene hdpe materials have improved significantly and now meet more stringent performance standards. Stress cracking sc is recognized as one of the major concerns for high density polyethylene hdpe pipes. Jan 08, 2020 additionally, they can be seamed and folded as needed without risking stress cracking. George wypych, in pvc formulary second edition, 2015. Aug 01, 2008 molded in stress can be another contributor to stress cracking. Esc is a major problem in the longterm service behavior of plastic products. However, below certain concentrations, which are representative of the commonly distributed natural gases, higher hydrocarbons have no detrimental effect on pvc pipe materials. These traits make pvc liners among the easiest to work with and install an especially big plus if youre planning to install your liner yourself. Technical note stress crack resistance for geomembrane products the stress crack resistance scr of polyethylene pe geomembranes has been the subject of study since the introduction of the materials over 20 years ago.
In summary, hdpe and pvc geomembranes should be formulated to resist the sitespecific environment but it appears that both geomembranes will provide adequate chemical resistance for msw landfills. These curves illustrate that hdpe has elasticplastic behaviour like the majority of. It has been estimated that 15% of all failures of plastic materials in. The nature of polyethylene pipe failure plasticstoday. Hdpe sheets stressrelieved s r these sheets have gone through an additional annealing process to reduce stress. This stress can be caused by a cavity pressure that is either too high or too low. Enhancing the environmental stress crack resistance of hdpe. Pvc pipe can be used for most any drain, water, or ventilation application.
Pvc can become brittle and crack when placed in a few scenarios for prolonged periods of time. Hdpe pipe heat fusion joining for strong, lifetime leak free joints flexible, fatigue resistant, light weight and impact resistant for easy, low cost installation resistance to environmental stress cracking resistant to surges and durable performance under temperature extremes. By environmental stress cracking, we understand a failure in which materials in contact with a. A products thermal stress cracking resistance tscr depends on the polymer compound formulation and the processing conditions under which the wire or cable was extruded, in addition to the temperature of the environment. Too many large organizations engage in unethical actions against smaller competitors. With hdpe, it was observed that slow cooling or annealing of the. The higher the density of the resin, the more likely the sheet is to. It is well known from the pipe and cable insulation industries that pe can stress crack over long periods of time. Grace hsuan, jy zhang and wk wong department of civil, architectural and environmental engineering, drexel university, philadelphia, usa abstract the 100year stress crack resistance scr of corrugated hdpe pipes was evaluated using a 600 mm diameter pipe. As for the general experiences with plastics in our countrywe refer to the literature 1234, in this paper we deal only with one aspect of pvc gas mains, the stress cracking phenomenon. During the summer months, stresscracking of hdpe containers reaches its peak. While crystallinity provides strength, it also can lead to. Because the mechanisms of failure for solvent attack and environmental stress cracking are so different, the means of optimizing material parameters are different as well. A materials resistance against this type of failure is called environmental stress cracking resistance escr.
Technical note stress crack resistance for geomembrane. While crystallinity provides strength, it also can lead to cracking. Ldpe is more likely to deform under tensile stress. Since variance of any of these factors can change the environmental stress crack resistance of the container, the test results are representative only of a given test performed under defined conditions in the laboratory. The mechanisms of environmental stress cracking proposed in the literature will be. Technical note stress crack resistance for geomembrane products. Escr problems get more pronounced in the summer, because of several factors related to increased heat and humidity. Natural gas condensate only affects pvc under extreme conditions which hardly ever occur.
The pipe industry is no exception and big manufacturers of hdpe pipe have recently gone on the attack against the smaller manufacturer of fusible pvc pipe, underground solutions, inc. There are now very few hdpe geomembranes that have scr times less than about 500 hr and some that have times in excess of 10,000 hr. There are now very few hdpe geomembranes that have scr times less than about. When a polymer is stressed in air to just below its yield point, stress cracking. It is the combination of stress and fluid contact that causes failure to occur much earlier than either component could achieve in isolation, if at all. The notched constant ligament stress ncls test astm 2163 was used for the pipe liner assessment. Experimental study of stress cracking in high density polyethylene pipes a thesis submitted to the faculty of drexel university by jingyu zhang. Hdpe, like steel, is a semicrystalline material, with no crystals in the melted state. Effects of recycled hdpe and nanoclay on stress cracking of.
Hdpe is more resistant to salt, corrosive materials and abrasion from sand, straw and dust, making it ideal for farm and industrial buildings. Hdpe is colored black to offer maximum resistance to stress cracking which is a common failure mode for this product. Crazing and cracking are strongly affected by the various gaseous environments. Environmental stress cracking esc is not the result of the continual battle that the plastics industry has in convincing environmentalists and politicians that plastics can be the solution to environmental problems and not the cause. Effects of recycled hdpe and nanoclay on stress cracking. The differences between pvc and hdpe lie both in the applications for each and their composition. Astm d2561 17 standard test method for environmental stress. The stress cracking is more severe with detergent, bleach, motor oil and some industrial chemical packaging. Stress cracking is essentially a brittle cracking phenomenon that occurs at a constant stress lower than the. Environmental stress cracking an overview sciencedirect.
The scr tests were performed on the finished pipe at the liner and junction locations. Exceeding the maximum pressure will cause the pipe walls to fail. Mdpe is often used for gas pipes, bags and packaging film. Thermal stress cracking can be minimized or eliminated by carefully choosing the polymer compound formulation and. A number of myths have arisen as to the causes and remedies for stresscracking. One of the most common causes of cracking and splitting in pvc pipes is overpressurization. Environmental stress cracking is considered to be the most frequent mode of failure of plastic materials. Diagnose it before it ruins your parts residual stress is an inherent result of plastics manufacturing processes and occurs when molten polymer is cooled and shaped. Sodium hypochlorite and its effects on polyethylene. Environmental stress cracking in polyethylene takes place because of interlamellar failure, which in turn is caused by relaxation of tie molecules. If you look at this plastic under a microscope, you would see that it has a linear structure with few branches lending to its optimal strengthdensity ratio.
As for the general experiences with plastics in our countrywe refer to the literature 1234, in this paper we deal only with one aspect of. Esc is the consequence of a combination of mechanical stress and exposure to an aggressive chemical. Standard test method for environmental stresscrack. The definition of stress cracking according to astm d883 is an external or internal crack in a plastic. Environmental stress cracking an overview sciencedirect topics. Experimental study of stress cracking in high density polyethylene. Additionally, they can be seamed and folded as needed without risking stress cracking. According to astm d883, stress cracking is defined as an external or internal crack in a plastic caused by tensile stresses less than its shortterm mechanical. According to astm d883, stress cracking is defined as an external or internal crack in a plastic caused. Mdpe exhibited excellent scg and stress crack resistance, and dominated pe pipe manufacture for 30 years until the development of bimodal hdpe pe100.
Polyethylene geomembranes are crystalline plastic and are subject to environmental stress cracking. Environment stress cracking of hdpe products is quite common due to its semi crystalline nature which gets attacked due to chemicals present in the environment. Jul 17, 2017 pvc pipe is a popular construction material for its low cost and durability. The solution to an internal part cracking problem is to change the packing pressure. Hence, an important design factor for pe pipes became commonly known as environmental stress cracking resistance escr, which led to the development of mdpe. Stress corrosion cracking of polyethylene practical. Environmental stress crack resistance escr testing of plastics. Premature cracking can be caused by topload stress, internal pressure, moldedin stress, and tail swing. Environmental stress cracking of polyvinyl chloride in. Basic understanding of stress cracking in hdpe products.
1127 1544 405 1354 461 296 430 7 940 1569 277 1317 1104 1504 1428 458 1204 908 1268 549 58 186 105 139 1291 1496 157 119 420 659 505 329 1041 1401 681 494 965 674 119 27 1387 163 1098 1227 1178